Probing Key Concepts of Medically assisted death. Analyzing the Portuguese Constitutional Court’s Rulings

Authors

  • Luís Cordeiro-Rodrigues Hunan University
  • Christopher Simon Wareham Utrecht University
  • João Cruz Ribeiro University of Minho

Keywords:

medically assisted death, portuguese constitutional court, unbearable suffering, vagueness and the law, permanent injury

Abstract

From 2021, the Portuguese parliament tried to get four versions of a law on medically assisted death approved. Two were rejected by the Portuguese Constitutional Court (PCC) because they were unconstitutional, and the President politically vetoed another. Finally, the parliament passed the law in 2023, even though the President and the PCC seem to oppose it. In this article, we analyze the PCC’s rulings on the medically assisted death law and contend that, broadly speaking, the PCC’s decisions to reject the law were justified. We focus on two core questions that have been critical in this debate: the meaning of ‘suffering’ and of ‘permanent injury of extreme gravity’. Further, we point to possible directions whereby the legislators may revise the law and thus solve the problems raised by the PCC.

Downloads

Published

2025-04-06

How to Cite

Cordeiro-Rodrigues, L. ., Wareham, C. S. ., & Cruz Ribeiro, J. . (2025). Probing Key Concepts of Medically assisted death. Analyzing the Portuguese Constitutional Court’s Rulings. Acta Bioethica, 31(1), 89–100. Retrieved from https://actabioethica.uchile.cl/index.php/AB/article/view/78374

Issue

Vol. 31 No. 1 (2025): NARRATIVAS, BIOÉTICA Y MEDICINA

Section

Original

License

Acta Bioethica is edited by the Interdisciplinary Center for Bioethical Studies of the University of Chile and published under a Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International license.Intellectual property::The submission and evaluation of the manuscripts received implies that the author (s) declare that they are original and exclusive owners of the author's economic and moral rights over the article, in accordance with the provisions of Law 17.336 on Intellectual Property (Chile) In case of having used outside works in the creation of the article, in whole or in part, they declare that they have the respective authorizations or licenses of use of their respective owners or that their use is expressly protected by law.The author expressly releases from any subsequent responsibility to the Interdisciplinary Center of Studies in Bioethics of the University of Chile, for any legal, regulatory or contractual infraction that eventually commits or has committed in relation to the work, being obliged to repair any damage that results from the Infringement of these or other rights.The author authorizes the Interdisciplinary Center of Studies in Bioethics of the University of Chile, in order that, by itself or through third parties expressly authorized by it, exercise the rights that are specified below, with respect to the article sent:Publication, edition, reproduction, adaptation, distribution and sale of reproduced copies, including making available to the public online by electronic or digital means, of the article, in Castilian language, in any known territory, And for all types of printed edition in paper and electronic or digital, by its inclusion in the journal Acta Bioethica or another publication that publishes the Center.This authorization is conferred on a non-exclusive, free, indefinite, perpetual and non-revocable basis, as long as the corresponding rights subsist and release the Interdisciplinary Center for Bioethical Studies of the University of Chile from any payment or remuneration for the exercise of Rights.The authors retain their copyright on their works, being able to reuse them as they decide.